Paper #467
- Title:
- An experimental test of loss aversion and scale compatibility
- Authors:
- Han Bleichrodt and José Luis Pinto
- Date:
- May 2000
- Abstract:
- This paper studies two important reasons why people violate procedure invariance, loss aversion and scale compatibility. The paper extends previous research on loss aversion and scale compatibility by studying loss aversion and scale compatibility simultaneously, by looking at a new decision domain, medical decision analysis, and by examining the effect of loss aversion and scale compatibility on "well-contemplated preferences." We find significant evidence both of loss aversion and scale compatibility. However, the sizes of the biases due to loss aversion and scale compatibility vary over trade-offs and most participants do not behave consistently according to loss aversion or scale compatibility. In particular, the effect of loss aversion in medical trade-offs decreases with duration. These findings are encouraging for utility measurement and prescriptive decision analysis. There appear to exist decision contexts in which the effects of loss aversion and scale compatibility can be minimized and utilities can be measured that do not suffer from these distorting factors.
- Keywords:
- Decision analysis, utility theory, loss aversion, scale compatibility, health
- JEL codes:
- C91, I10, D81
- Area of Research:
- Microeconomics
- CRES Series number:
- 12
- Published in:
- Journal of Mathematical Psychology, 46, 3, (2002), pp. 315-337
With the title:
Loss Aversion and Scale Compatibility in Two-Attributive Trade-Offs
Download the paper in PDF format