Paper #305

Title:

Window-dressing in German interwar balance sheets

Author:

Mark Spoerer

Date:

July 1998

Abstract:

German accounting rules value assets and liabilities asymmetrically and thus lead to grossly distorted balance sheets. In the interwar debate on a reform of disclosure regulation, financial experts considered the (undisclosed) tax balance sheet, which had to be drawn up separately for the corporate tax assessment, as a paradigm for adequate financial disclosure. However, due to tax secrecy thay were barred from analyzing tax documents. Using archival evidence, we analyze tax balance sheets from which the reliability of disclosed balance sheets of the interwar period can be assessed. It emerges that companies overstated their profits in the middand late 1920s, but grossly understated them in the Nazi economy.

Keywords:

Germany, accounting history, window-dressing, tax balance sheet

JEL codes:

N24

Area of Research:

Finance and Accounting

Published in:

Accounting, Business & Financial History, volume 8, number 3, 351-369, November 1998

Download the paper in PDF format